The best answer is two-factor authentication such as a USB ikey token which
is technically identical to a ATM card. It carries the identity of the user
and the shared secret for authentication is programmed onto the key and
encrypted. It is much more secure then username and passwords and is
actually easier to use since the only thing the user needs to remember is
their pin number. Two-factor authentication means 1) something you have (Key
token) with something only you know (pin) so it does not matter if either is
lost or stolen since you need both (hence two-factor) to get access, again
the same as your ATM card.
People are familiar with ATM cards so the education issue is simple and
again a two-factor token is more secure then complicated passwords that a
user will write down which defeats the security....right????
Mary Ann Burns
-----Original Message-----
From: Saqib Ali [mailto:docbook.xml@gmail.com]
Sent: Monday, April 18, 2005 12:56 PM
To: James Barkley
Cc: webappsec@securityfocus.com
Subject: Re: suggesting passwds to users
I suppose you could generate word-form passwords such as g@L@xi3$
(galaxies) to try and manage the user. You have to compare the
threats: is it more of a threat for a user to write down their
password or to use the same password they have on 50 other web sites.
I'm not sure what the answer is here....
Yup the answer will depend on your application, and the env you users are
working in.
No offense, but DUH! Isn't it impossible for a computer to generate a
truly random number without user interaction (such as random mouse
movements to generate entropy, as gnupg asks the user to do when
generating pub/priv keypairs)? Nevertheless, as your
pseudo-randomness tends toward zero you will hit a point that is
statistically acceptable. Like when scientists agree that 1x10^-200
chance of occurence can reasonably be considered impossible.
I m not going to comment on this :)
This is a not a bad idea, but I'm not sure my server can handle doing
a dictionary/bruteforce attack on a user chosen password on the fly in
enough time to return a response to the user. Some of these systems
You don't have to do it on-the-fly. You can run a CRON job on a nightly
basis to do thorough verification of the password complexity.
And prompt the user to change when they log in next time.
--
In Peace,
Saqib Ali
http://validate.sf.net
