I respectfully disagree with this proposal and maybe we should discuss it.
Being a member of the admin group is NOT 100% equal to being root. Therefore
when you switch from admin group to uid=0 you are escalating privileges. A
trojan that gets control of an admin's session should not be able to escalate
itself to root without a password prompt, which requires a human to decide
(rightly or wrongly...) yes I do want to increase the authority of this process.
Sure, an admin should be smart enough not to get trojaned, but what if they do
anyway?
Maybe a cracker could write a trojan that esclates itself using the powers of
the admin group, but why make it easier for those who don't know how?
The myth that it should be easy for uneducated users to expose their computers
to harm is one reason why certain other GUI platforms have so many security
problems.
host:/tmp1 sysmsimkin$ id
uid=505(sysmsimkin) gid=505(sysmsimkin) groups=505(sysmsimkin),
81(appserveradm), 79(appserverusr), 80(admin)
host:/tmp1 sysmsimkin$ ls -ld /tmp1
drwxr-xr-x 3 501 admin 102 Jun 28 2006 /tmp1
host:/tmp1 sysmsimkin$ mkdir /tmp1/tmp2
mkdir: /tmp1/tmp2: Permission denied
host:/tmp1 sysmsimkin$ /usr/bin/sudo /bin/bash
Password:
host:/tmp1 root# mkdir /tmp1/tmp2
host:/tmp1 root# ls -ld /tmp1/tmp2
drwxr-xr-x 2 root admin 68 Jan 25 11:20 /tmp1/tmp2
host:/tmp1 root# exit
host:/tmp1 sysmsimkin$ rmdir /tmp1/tmp2
rmdir: /tmp1/tmp2: Permission denied
host:/tmp1 sysmsimkin$ /usr/bin/sudo /bin/bash
host:/tmp1 root# rmdir /tmp1/tmp2
host:/tmp1 root# exit
host:/tmp1 sysmsimkin$
More interesting (to me) why wasn't I prompted for a password the second time?
(Yes I know it was designed that way, I'm asking was that the right decision.)
Presumably there is a window of vulnerability for a few minutes AFTER you have
been root during which you could fall victim to a trojan.
-------------------------------------
Marvin Simkin
Planetary Geology Group
School of Earth and Space Exploration
Arizona State University
http://simkin.asu.edu/
-----Original Message-----
From: K F (lists) [mailto:kf_lists@digitalmunition.com]
Sent: Wed 2007-01-24 18:20
To: bugtraq@securityfocus.com
Subject: Remove all admin->root authorization prompts from OSX
http://www.petitiononline.com/31337OSX/petition.html
-KF
