Re: Write-up by Amit Klein: "Forging HTTP request headers with Flash"

On 26 Jul 2006 at 22:43, 3CO wrote:

> FYI Flash9 added a new property for object and embed tags to prevent
> this technique from being used: "allowNetworking":
> http://livedocs.macromedia.com/flex/2/docs/wwhelp/wwhimpl/common/html/wwhelp.htm?context=LiveDocs_Parts&file=00001590.html
>
> That page doesn't explicitly list LoadVars as being disallowed, but I
> just tested, and it is true.

The way I understand that help page, allowNetworking is part of the 
OBJECT/EMBED tag. Now,
keep in mind that in the attack vectors described in my paper, the victim 
user/browser
visits a malicious site (e.g. by clicking a malicious link), so the way Flash 
is invoked
is completely controlled by the attacker (either the attacker provides the 
Flash object 
directly, by a link ending with ".swf", or the attacker provides a link to an 
HTML page
containing an OBJECT/EMBED tag). And the attacker would surely not include the 
allowNetworking attribute in his/her page ;-)

> For instance, Myspace has added that to all embed tags to prevent fun
> from occurring.

That's a different story. MySpace faces a much more complex situation, wherein 
the attacker
may very well be a user in MySpace allowed to upload HTML pages and Flash 
objects/links to
MySpace. In MySpace's context, allowNetworking may be more relevant.

> Great paper though (as usual); thanks.

Thanks for reading :-)

-Amit