Re: Ping, ICMP and TCP Ping

zaka rias wrote:
> hi,
>
> Im learning protocol tcp/ip and icmp, and as far as i
> know that Ping (software) is using ICMP protocol to
> transmit packets and PING is identic with ICMP.

Not sure what you meant but this should clear you it up a bit:

DESCRIPTION
       ping uses the ICMP protocol's mandatory ECHO_REQUEST datagram to
elicit an  ICMP  ECHO_RESPONSE from a host or gateway.  ECHO_REQUEST
datagrams (``pings'') have an IP and ICMP header


This comes from a linux ping(8) man page.



> I have always wrapped my thinking that ICMP (and Ping
> Program) echo/reply was a port 0 thing (like someone
> said in
> http://forum.sans.org/discus/messages/78/10869.html?1110164175
> ), and that's wrong.

Well, I believe the post By T. Brian Granier (bgranier) is correct. It's
not about ports, it's about codes and types.

ftp://ftp.rfc-editor.org/in-notes/rfc792.txt



> i just wonder if this kind of method called TCP-PING,
> when actually TCP-PING isnt using ICMP protocol, and
> once more ->  TCP PING 's using port when actually
> PING program is not using a port to communicate.

ping(8) does not uses a port to communicate because it's based on ICMP.
TCP-PING method on the other hand works by sending a TCP ack packet to a
specified port, no it DOESN'T use ICMP. I believe this METHOD is called
TCP-PING because it can be used to perform a similar function as ICMP
ping, to determine if a machine is up.

man nmap(1) and read the Ping scanning description, be sure to read the
ACK scan too.



luck