It always surprises me. Security should be rational and quelling fear. We
should be the ones with the calm heads, who verify rumours and innuendo.
Yet this is not the case. Here we are leading with FUD.
First, an intro to materials science for drive platters. Glass is a liquid as
hard as it may seem to some of you. It has an incredibly high viscosity but it
does flow. What this means is that it is not used in drives. Rather, glass
crystal is. This has a large number of shear planes. Think of it like your car
windows. It will not break nicely. It will not be reconstructed if it breaks.
The film amalgam on the platter will also not maintain its magnetic field on
the platter breaking. The shear stresses change the field density.
With the configurations today, they may not always break ? thus it is a good
idea to see them. You can not control where and how they hit, but the chances
are good that they will break. Opening it is still better it is guaranteed.
Next wiping. There is not any great new tech to un-wipe drives. There is
nothing short of a slow and erroneous reconstruction ? bit by bit by bit, over
years using very slow and very inaccurate techniques.
The issue with wiping is it able to be un-wiped ? as this is just an urban
legend, but was it done correctly and was ALL the drive wiped (Linux dd misses
a sector for instance).
So basically, there is no magic un-wipe tech. There is no reconstruction tech.
Unless Star Trek was right and in the next 50 years or so life as we know it
changes due to interstellar travel etc, there is nothing coming to do this.
Regards,
Craig
-----Original Message-----
Bill,
I know your task may be fun and have good intentions, but unless you
opened the drive and verified that the platters are destroyed to the
point where nobody can put it back together, then you are just doing the
same thing as someone who formats a drive.
From an audit point of view, I think they would have the same question.
With Sarbox and other audit requirements, I have to provide proof that
the task was completed.
<<got the wrong person before>> Robert works for the govt. I am sure he
can tell you that per dod and audit standards, he will not be allowed to
just drop a drive on the pavement and not verify that it was destroyed.
Anyway.. as I mentioned before, the Solaris format/purge command is free
and does do the job. (I think it also follows dod standards)
-----Original Message-----
From: Bill Stout [mailto:billbrietstout@yahoo.com]
Sent: Monday, September 17, 2007 12:39 PM
To: Levenglick, Jeff; Holstein, Robert - BLS CTR;
pen-test@securityfocus.com
Subject: Re: Wiping Solaris Servers
I think pebbles of glass are equivalent to shredding, especially for a
commercial environment. Slamming a hard drive against pavement does
meet the "so easy a monkey could perform the task" requirement. Plus
it's fun.
What I was inferring to was the value of the hard drives themselves, and
if they needed to be included with the system. It's faster and easier
to verify a physically destroyed disk or just not ship it, than trust
that a warehouse monkey run through a boot/wipe/verify process. Does
the warehouse have the right power connector? Do they have the right
keyboard and monitor? Is the system complete or have all the parts
needed to wipe the disk?
Near-future or existing unknown recovery techniques might be able to
recover from wiped disks. For example, recorded encrypted conversations
from 10 years ago (and newer) are easily decrypted these days, and back
then the decryption techniques of the day were thought to take up to
30years.
Bill Stout
------------------------------------------------------------------------
This list is sponsored by: Cenzic
Need to secure your web apps NOW?
Cenzic finds more, "real" vulnerabilities fast.
Click to try it, buy it or download a solution FREE today!
http://www.cenzic.com/downloads
------------------------------------------------------------------------
