In this case it may appear wiser and cost effective for you to evaluate a
Managed Service Provider.
If your objective is to evaluate just HIDS and report the findings, then you
should certainly start with finacksyn's question as a good RFI.
I would get a Value Added Re-Seller on your side so that you do not get
courted and spun into "WishWare" like I have seen too many times. Make the
VAR help you.
Now, if you have the dollars to research, evaluate, test, and purchase a
holistic information security infrastructure; then, you will want to bring
in an MSSP. It is proven that the annual investment of a Security Service
Provider has a far greater return and less investment in resources and
"Tools" than you or your organization can provide.
Bottom line: Poor soldiers like you and I know what makes sense for InfoSec
and what does not (Meaning what we can really monitor, manage, administer,
and learn with little staff/resources/pay). "They" make decisions based
upon "flavor of the month security manufacturer". "They" are smart, don't
get me wrong. In fact their job stinks and I would not want it (Politics).
MSSP's are worth looking into in your world. Be aware! MSSP's make claims,
over state Scope of Work, only support product/technology that you do not
already own, and a lot of them only will provide you with a very limited
scope of services (Monitor but no vulnerability mitigation, vulnerability
assessment, but no monitoring of applications, OS, database,... (Which, IMHO
is stupid).
I hope this helps. I too have 10+ years experience as an administrator,
security software sales engineer, security product manager of an IDS, and a
MSSP.
This post is strictly from me and my opinion. Any response or solicitation
should be replied back to the list.
Gregg Earnhart
Plano, TX
-----Original Message-----
From: Paul Schmehl [mailto:pauls@utdallas.edu]
Sent: Thursday, February 02, 2006 8:38 PM
To: focus-ids@securityfocus.com
Subject: Re: Real world experience with HIDS
The problem with your response is it makes assumptions about my
infrastructure and my needs (which I won't reveal on this list.) In the
real world (at least mine), I don't get to make the decisions about "what's
best" for someone else's equipment. If they want HIDS, not HIPS, then
that's what I'm going to research.
Active defense is nice, but when it gets in the way of operations, decision
makers won't allow it, in some case, even if it's what we would recommend.
Sometimes, as security professionals, we have to skin cats with other
things than the best knives.
--On February 3, 2006 12:51:37 AM +0000 FinAckSyn <finacksyn@yahoo.co.uk>
wrote:
Hi Paul,
Don't take this the wrong way, but you're asking the
wrong questions! :)
1) Ease of install - can it be done through GPO?
SMS? Login scripts?
Zero-day attack prevention is far more important than
ease of use. DON'T choose a
well-orchestrated/marketed product if it doesn't give
you the protection you need.
2) Usefulness of the information generated - have
you detected any
exploits? How were you notified? Etc.,
The whole point of HIDS/HIPS should be to give you a
last line of defence, once attackers/hackers/worms
have got through your perimeter security. Screw
detection at this point. You need active protection.
3) Centralized management - is there any? If so,
how easy is it to use?
Configurable at the host level? Or group of hosts
level?
There aren't any commerical HIPS/HIDS products that
don't give you this.
4) Access to data - is it possible to restrict
access to the data so that
an administrator on the server would *not* be able
to see the output of the
HIDS?
Setup separate 'security administrator' accounts, that
separate day to day security event logging from day to
day account administration.
5) Interference with the server - does it consume
lots of memory or CPU?
Only if they're badly written.
Is it proactive or passive?
Ignore any passive products. If an attacker has got
through all your other protection (firewall, AV, IPS,
IDS) then a passive product is not going to help you.
6) Would you purchase again, if you had the option?
PLEASE NOTE: Any vendor on this list who emails me
suggesting their
product will be automatically dropped from
consideration, so be forewarned.
You're welcome to respond on the list, if you like,
but don't email me or you'll be eliminated from
consideration.
I work for Cisco, Juniper, ISS, McAfee, Symantec,
Trend and Check Point, and recommend them all
throroughly. Does this mean you'll drop the whole
marketplace from consideration now ? :)
--- Paul Schmehl <pauls@utdallas.edu> wrote:
I have some questions for real world users (not
vendors) of HIDS products.
If you are using HIDS products *and* you're happy
with the results, please
respond to the following quesitons.
1) Ease of install - can it be done through GPO?
SMS? Login scripts?
2) Usefulness of the information generated - have
you detected any
exploits? How were you notified? Etc.,
3) Centralized management - is there any? If so,
how easy is it to use?
Configurable at the host level? Or group of hosts
level?
4) Access to data - is it possible to restrict
access to the data so that
an administrator on the server would *not* be able
to see the output of the
HIDS?
5) Interference with the server - does it consume
lots of memory or CPU?
Is it proactive or passive?
6) Would you purchase again, if you had the option?
PLEASE NOTE: Any vendor on this list who emails me
suggesting their
product will be automatically dropped from
consideration, so be forewarned.
You're welcome to respond on the list, if you like,
but don't email me or
you'll be eliminated from consideration.
Paul Schmehl (pauls@utdallas.edu)
Adjunct Information Security Officer
University of Texas at Dallas
AVIEN Founding Member
http://www.utdallas.edu/ir/security/
------------------------------------------------------------------------
Test Your IDS
Is your IDS deployed correctly?
Find out quickly and easily by testing it
with real-world attacks from CORE IMPACT.
Go to
http://www.securityfocus.com/sponsor/CoreSecurity_focus-ids_040708
to learn more.
------------------------------------------------------------------------
___________________________________________________________
Yahoo! Photos - NEW, now offering a quality print service from just 8p
a photo http://uk.photos.yahoo.com
Paul Schmehl (pauls@utdallas.edu)
Adjunct Information Security Officer
University of Texas at Dallas
AVIEN Founding Member
http://www.utdallas.edu/
------------------------------------------------------------------------
Test Your IDS
Is your IDS deployed correctly?
Find out quickly and easily by testing it
with real-world attacks from CORE IMPACT.
Go to http://www.securityfocus.com/sponsor/CoreSecurity_focus-ids_040708
to learn more.
------------------------------------------------------------------------
------------------------------------------------------------------------
Test Your IDS
Is your IDS deployed correctly?
Find out quickly and easily by testing it
with real-world attacks from CORE IMPACT.
Go to http://www.securityfocus.com/sponsor/CoreSecurity_focus-ids_040708
to learn more.
------------------------------------------------------------------------
